... without ever having read the books.
I know, I know. But hear me out. I haven't read the books for good reason. I've heard so much about them, dissecting them to death, parodies of them, etc, that I honestly just don't think I could read them with a fair eye at this point. I'd be so biased just going in. Plus, from what I've heard about the story, it just doesn't appeal to me.
That being said, I think I may have figured out the appeal.
Now, I know Edward and Bella are said to have an unhealthy, even abusive relationship. And that there's lots of fucked up stuff in the books, probably due to Stephenie Meyer being Mormon. Or maybe just due to Stephenie Meyer being fucked up. But in any case, yeah I'm not advocating Edward's and Bella's relationship as some sort of ideal.
From what I've heard, Edward and Bella don't have sex until fairly late into their relationship, and Bella's definitely the aggressor. She's the one pushing for sex all along, and he's holding back because he's afraid he'll hurt her, being a vampire and all. And when they finally Do It, it's the most explosively awesome thing ever, which ultimately results in a baby that has soap opera rapid aging syndrome. But that's neither here nor there.
The point is that she pushes and pushes, and he's the one to hold back. Pretty much the complete opposite of what most women have to deal with in real life. Oh and they eventually get to have sex but she gets to stay the Good Girl, because they're married and it results in a baby and stuff.
So yeah, I can see how that could seem like a pretty awesome fantasy on that level. She gets to have her sexuality without pressure or judgement.
So I'm not saying these are great books or anything (I can't, since I've never read them). But I have the feeling that I've figured out what their appeal might be.